Coinbase Initiates Intermediate Appeal in SEC Lawsuit

Coinbase is pursuing an interlocutory appeal in its ongoing lawsuit against the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), a case that has been closely watched since its inception in June 2023. On April 12, the leading American cryptocurrency exchange filed a motion seeking judicial clarification on a pivotal legal question, as it defends against the SEC’s claims that it has operated as an unregistered securities exchange, broker, and clearing agency.

This move is part of Coinbase’s broader strategy to challenge the SEC’s actions after its initial motion to dismiss the allegations was denied by the court. As the largest crypto exchange in the U.S. with 73 million users, Coinbase has been outspoken about the need for a definitive regulatory framework for cryptocurrencies and has consistently criticized the SEC’s aggressive approach towards the digital asset sector.

Coinbase Advocates for Review Before Case Conclusion

Unlike typical appeals which are processed post-trial or after a lower court’s final verdict, interlocutory appeals allow for certain judicial decisions to be reviewed before a case is fully resolved. In SEC v. Coinbase, the exchange seeks to clarify the legal definition of an investment contract as it applies to cryptocurrency transactions.

Coinbase asserts that their request for an interlocutory appeal meets all necessary legal criteria. The key legal question involves whether an investment contract can exist in transactions that lack ongoing post-sale obligations.

Additionally, Coinbase points out that there is significant disagreement regarding how the Howey Test, which determines if a transaction qualifies as an investment contract, should be applied to cryptocurrency transactions. The exchange argues that resolving this question could decisively impact the SEC’s main allegations in the lawsuit, underscoring the appeal’s importance.

The court is set to review Coinbase’s request for an interlocutory appeal. If approved, the pivotal legal question will be forwarded to an appellate court for further examination and resolution.

Coinbase CLO Highlights Appeal’s Importance for Crypto Industry

Paul Grewal, Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer, emphasized the significance of the interlocutory appeal for the broader cryptocurrency industry, especially given the SEC’s stringent enforcement actions amid a vague regulatory landscape. Grewal highlighted that addressing these critical legal questions is crucial for establishing a fair and clear regulatory framework for cryptocurrencies.

Total crypto market cap valued at $2.239 trillion on the daily chart